NEW DELHI
More than a century after Birsa Munda challenged colonial dispossession through the Ulgulan, India has developed an extensive constitutional and legal framework to protect the land, forests and traditional rights of tribal communities. Yet, continuing disputes over mining, forest diversion, land acquisition and displacement raise a fundamental question: why does the struggle for Adivasi land rights persist despite these safeguards?
The Constitution’s Fifth and Sixth Schedules, the Panchayats (Extension to Scheduled Areas) Act, 1996 (PESA), the Forest Rights Act, 2006 (FRA), and the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, provide important safeguards. However, their implementation involves different institutions, jurisdictions and legal requirements, with varying outcomes across regions.
Forest Rights Act: Recognition Remains Incomplete
The FRA was enacted to address historical injustice arising from the inadequate recognition of the rights of forest-dwelling Scheduled Tribes and other traditional forest dwellers. It recognises individual rights over forest land under occupation and community rights over traditional resources, including minor forest produce, grazing, fishing and other customary uses. It also provides for Community Forest Resource rights, enabling eligible communities to protect, regenerate, conserve and manage forests traditionally used by them.
Gram Sabhas have a central role in initiating the process of determining these rights. Yet, official figures indicate that recognition remains incomplete.
According to the Ministry of Tribal Affairs’ response to a Rajya Sabha question on August 12, 2026, a total of 54,01,561 individual and community forest rights claims had been received across India up to June 30, 2026. Of these, 25,42,359 titles had been distributed, 18,13,232 claims rejected and 10,45,970 remained pending.
The State-wise figures reveal considerable differences. Chhattisgarh had received 9,47,479 claims and distributed 5,34,068 titles. Odisha had received 7,69,977 claims and distributed 4,73,936 titles. Madhya Pradesh had received 8,07,405 claims but distributed 2,89,461 titles, with 2,73,457 pending. Telangana had received 6,55,249 claims, distributed 2,31,456 titles and had 3,29,367 pending. Karnataka had received 2,95,176 claims and distributed just 16,700 titles, while 2,62,626 had been rejected.
These figures do not establish that every rejected claim was valid or that every pending claim represents an unlawful denial. Eligibility and evidence requirements must be considered. Nevertheless, the scale of unresolved claims and the wide differences in state-level performance warrant scrutiny.
The distinction between individual and community rights is also significant. Of the total claims, 51,86,693 were individual and 2,14,868 community claims. Titles distributed comprised 24,18,197 individual and 1,24,162 community titles. These categories represent different kinds of rights and are not directly comparable measures of land or beneficiaries. However, the figures underline the need to examine whether collective community rights are receiving adequate attention.
Centre’s Admission: A National Data Gap
In a Lok Sabha response published on August 6, 2026, the Ministry of Tribal Affairs stated that it does not centrally maintain details of tribal land diversion or disputes relating to land acquisition, rehabilitation and implementation of Gram Sabha consent provisions in mining and other diversion projects.
The Ministry cited the constitutional jurisdiction of state governments over land and its management, as well as the responsibilities of other Union ministries. It identified six pending legal matters concerning diversion of tribal land in Scheduled Areas: three involving mining projects in Odisha, two concerning national highway construction or widening in Gujarat and one relating to a hydroelectric project in Himachal Pradesh.
This does not mean project-level information is unavailable. The Environment Ministry, for instance, processes forest diversion proposals through the PARIVESH portal. The gap is the absence of a consolidated national picture covering tribal land diversion, displacement, rehabilitation, restoration of illegally transferred land and disputes over community rights.
Without such information, it is difficult to assess the cumulative impact of development projects, track rehabilitation or determine whether legal safeguards are working. It also limits public accountability by making it harder to establish how much tribal land has been diverted, how many affected families have been rehabilitated and how many restoration cases remain unresolved.
PESA: Promise Of Self-Governance
Enacted in 1996, PESA extended the constitutional provisions relating to Panchayati Raj to Fifth Schedule areas while recognising customary practices and traditional systems of community governance. It gives Gram Sabhas an important role in protecting customary traditions, cultural identity and community resources.
The Act provides for consultation with Gram Sabhas or Panchayats at the appropriate level before land acquisition for development projects and before the resettlement or rehabilitation of affected persons in Scheduled Areas. It also requires their recommendations before prospecting licences or mining leases for minor minerals are granted and before auctions of minor minerals in these areas.
An important legal distinction is that PESA provides for consultation before land acquisition, whereas the separate land acquisition law requires prior consent in specified circumstances.
Section 41 of the 2013 Land Acquisition Act provides that, as far as possible, no land should be acquired in Scheduled Areas. Where acquisition is undertaken under the Act, prior consent of the Gram Sabha, Panchayat or Autonomous District Council, as applicable, is required before the notification under Section 11. Consultation and consent are not interchangeable requirements.
The effectiveness of these safeguards depends on whether Gram Sabhas receive complete information, meetings follow prescribed procedures and their statutory role is respected by government departments and project authorities. PESA applies to Fifth Schedule areas; it does not automatically extend to Sixth Schedule areas, which have a separate constitutional governance framework.
Constitutional Safeguards: Different Regions, Different Protections
The Fifth and Sixth Schedules recognise the distinct circumstances of tribal communities through special arrangements for governance and protection.
The Fifth Schedule covers Scheduled Areas in ten states: Andhra Pradesh, Telangana, Chhattisgarh, Gujarat, Himachal Pradesh, Jharkhand, Madhya Pradesh, Maharashtra, Odisha and Rajasthan. It empowers Governors to make regulations for the peace and good government of these areas, including provisions to prohibit or restrict the transfer of land by or among members of Scheduled Tribes and regulate land allotment to tribal communities.
The Sixth Schedule provides for autonomous district and regional councils in specified tribal areas of Assam, Meghalaya, Tripura and Mizoram. These bodies exercise legislative, judicial and administrative powers in specified matters, including aspects of land and customary governance.
The arrangements recognise that conventional land administration may not adequately accommodate customary ownership and community institutions. However, protections differ according to the constitutional status of an area, applicable state laws and customary systems. The existence of a protective provision does not, by itself, ensure enforcement.
Illegal Transfers, Implementation Challenge
Several states have protective tenancy and land-transfer laws intended to prevent or reverse tribal land alienation. The Chotanagpur Tenancy Act and Santhal Parganas tenancy framework in Jharkhand, for instance, restrict specified transfers of tribal land and provide for restoration in cases covered by law.
In Andhra Pradesh, the Scheduled Areas Land Transfer Regulation, 1959, as amended in 1970, was interpreted by the Supreme Court in the Samatha judgment to protect tribal land in Scheduled Areas from prohibited transfers to non-tribals.
Enforcement, however, is complicated by outdated land records, disputed ownership, incomplete surveys, informal transactions, administrative delays and litigation. The problem is particularly serious where customary rights have never been formally recorded or official land classifications do not reflect actual community use.
A family may hold a title to agricultural land while its access to grazing grounds, forests, water sources and other common resources remains disputed or undocumented. Land protection must therefore extend beyond individual ownership documents to include community rights, customary use and traditional access to natural resources.

The High Level Committee on the Socio-Economic, Health and Educational Status of Tribal Communities of India, chaired by Virginius Xaxa and constituted in 2013, examined the interconnected problems of land alienation, displacement, migration, livelihoods and implementation of constitutional safeguards. Its 2014 report remains an important national reference for understanding why tribal development cannot be assessed solely through economic indicators without accounting for land loss and displacement.
What Needs To Change?
India needs a publicly accessible, regularly updated national database covering tribal land acquisition, forest diversion, displacement, rehabilitation, restoration cases and compliance with statutory consultation and consent requirements.
States must undertake time-bound verification and disposal of forest rights claims, provide transparent reasons for rejection and ensure effective appeal mechanisms. Community Forest Resource rights must receive greater attention alongside individual titles, with Gram Sabhas given the institutional capacity, technical assistance and information needed to exercise their responsibilities.
Land records must be updated and reconciled with customary rights, community resources and traditional village boundaries. Digitisation should not substitute for resolving legitimate customary and ownership claims.
Rehabilitation must be assessed through the restoration of sustainable livelihoods, access to common resources, social security and cultural continuity, rather than compensation payments alone. Women’s participation in land ownership, forest rights claims and community decision-making must also be strengthened, given their dependence on forests and common resources.
Real Test Of Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas
Birsa Munda’s struggle emerged when Adivasi communities were losing control over ancestral land and traditional institutions. The Ulgulan challenged not only colonial authority but also the systems that enabled dispossession and exploitation.
India today has constitutional and legal instruments that did not exist during Birsa’s lifetime. The FRA, PESA, Fifth and Sixth Schedules and protective land laws represent important advances. The Supreme Court’s Niyamgiri judgment demonstrated that customary, cultural and religious rights can play a decisive role in decisions affecting tribal territories. Yet, national FRA figures show that recognition of individual and community rights remains incomplete, while the absence of consolidated information on tribal land diversion makes accountability difficult.
As the country observes Janjatiya Gaurav Diwas on November 15, Birsa’s legacy must be assessed through the lived realities of Adivasi communities across India. The Ulgulan belongs to history, but the questions of land, dignity, identity and self-governance that shaped it remain central to the country’s development debate.
The ultimate test is not how frequently India remembers Birsa Munda, but whether Adivasi communities can retain their ancestral land, protect their forests, preserve their cultural landscapes and exercise a meaningful voice over their future. That remains the unfinished promise of Birsa Munda’s struggle.
Ends















