• About
  • Contact
  • Sitemap
  • Gallery
No Result
View All Result
Vacancies
Tuesday, May 6, 2025
The Indian Tribal
  • Home
  • Achievers
    • उपलब्धिकर्ता
  • Cuisine
    • खान पान
  • Health
    • स्वास्थ्य
  • Legal
    • कानूनी
  • Music
    • संगीत
  • News
    • Updates
    • खबरें
  • Sports
    • खेलकूद
  • Variety
    • विविध
  • हिंदी
    • All
    • आदिवासी
    • उपलब्धिकर्ता
    • कला और संस्कृति
    • कानूनी
    • खबरें
    • खान पान
    • खेलकूद
    • जनजाति
    • भारत
    • विविध
    • संगीत
    • संस्कृति
    • स्वास्थ्य
    झारखंड सरकार के वित्त मंत्री राधा कृष्ण किशोर ने सोमवार को 1 लाख 45 हजार 400 करोड़ रुपये का वार्षिक बजट प्रस्तुत किया।

    झारखंड में बनेगा जनजातीय विश्वविद्यालय 

    The Indian Tribal

    सौर ऊर्जा ने भगाया अंधेरा, झिलमिला उठे आदिवासियों के भविष्य के सपने

    The Indian Tribal

    जनजातीय स्वतंत्रता सेनानियों के गौरव को चित्रों में उकेरने की अनूठी पहल

    The Indian Tribal

    झारखण्ड के महान विभूतियों की संघर्ष गाथा हमारे लिए प्रेरणास्रोत हैं: मुख्यमंत्री हेमन्त सोरेन

    The Indian Tribal

    खरसावां शहीद स्मारक को विश्व पटल पर एक अलग पहचान दिलाएंगे: हेमन्त सोरेन

    Bastar Touris,

    इंजीनियरिंग ग्रेजुएट ने पर्यटन गाइड बन आदिवासी जीवन को दुनिया के समक्ष लाने का बीड़ा उठाया है

    Surrendered Naxalites - The Indian Tribal

    कभी थी पुलिस उनके पीछे, आज पुलिस बन वे नक्सलियों के पीछे

    The Indian Tribal

    मुख्यमंत्री हेमन्त सोरेन के हस्तक्षेप पर 17 साल बाद आदिम जनजाति युवक को मिला न्याय

  • Gallery
    • Videos
  • Latest News
The Indian Tribal
  • Home
  • Achievers
    • उपलब्धिकर्ता
  • Cuisine
    • खान पान
  • Health
    • स्वास्थ्य
  • Legal
    • कानूनी
  • Music
    • संगीत
  • News
    • Updates
    • खबरें
  • Sports
    • खेलकूद
  • Variety
    • विविध
  • हिंदी
    • All
    • आदिवासी
    • उपलब्धिकर्ता
    • कला और संस्कृति
    • कानूनी
    • खबरें
    • खान पान
    • खेलकूद
    • जनजाति
    • भारत
    • विविध
    • संगीत
    • संस्कृति
    • स्वास्थ्य
    झारखंड सरकार के वित्त मंत्री राधा कृष्ण किशोर ने सोमवार को 1 लाख 45 हजार 400 करोड़ रुपये का वार्षिक बजट प्रस्तुत किया।

    झारखंड में बनेगा जनजातीय विश्वविद्यालय 

    The Indian Tribal

    सौर ऊर्जा ने भगाया अंधेरा, झिलमिला उठे आदिवासियों के भविष्य के सपने

    The Indian Tribal

    जनजातीय स्वतंत्रता सेनानियों के गौरव को चित्रों में उकेरने की अनूठी पहल

    The Indian Tribal

    झारखण्ड के महान विभूतियों की संघर्ष गाथा हमारे लिए प्रेरणास्रोत हैं: मुख्यमंत्री हेमन्त सोरेन

    The Indian Tribal

    खरसावां शहीद स्मारक को विश्व पटल पर एक अलग पहचान दिलाएंगे: हेमन्त सोरेन

    Bastar Touris,

    इंजीनियरिंग ग्रेजुएट ने पर्यटन गाइड बन आदिवासी जीवन को दुनिया के समक्ष लाने का बीड़ा उठाया है

    Surrendered Naxalites - The Indian Tribal

    कभी थी पुलिस उनके पीछे, आज पुलिस बन वे नक्सलियों के पीछे

    The Indian Tribal

    मुख्यमंत्री हेमन्त सोरेन के हस्तक्षेप पर 17 साल बाद आदिम जनजाति युवक को मिला न्याय

  • Gallery
    • Videos
  • Latest News
No Result
View All Result
The Indian Tribal
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Achievers
  • Cuisine
  • Health
  • Legal
  • Music
  • News
  • Sports
  • Variety
  • हिंदी
  • Gallery
  • Latest News
Vacancies
Home » The Indian Tribal / News » SC puts ball in Govt court over reservation in promotion to SC/STs

SC puts ball in Govt court over reservation in promotion to SC/STs

Refusing to lay down any yardstick for granting reservation in promotion to SC/STs in Government jobs, the Supreme Court on Friday said Centre and states cannot escape from providing quantifiable data to justify its provision to them. So what does the Government do now?

January 28, 2022
Supreme court of India

Supreme Court Of India

Indian Tribal News Service

New Delhi

The Supreme Court has reiterated that Centre and states cannot escape from providing quantifiable data to justify reservation in promotion to Scheduled Castes and Scheduled  Tribes in Government jobs.

This data, according to the Court, has to show inadequate representation of SC/STs in public employment taking each cadre as a unit that should not be for all times but be open for review after a reasonable period. 

After the judgment, two major issues confront the government – what yardstick to adopt for determining inadequate representation in promotional posts. Should it be based on population of SC/ST in the country vis-à-vis the entire population of the country or some other yardstick has to be adopted. This question has been left open for determination by the Centre.

And the other question confronting the government is – the criteria for measuring adequacy of representation of SC/ST should be reviewed after how many years. All that the Court has said is that this review is mandatory and should be done within a reasonable period. What constitutes “reasonable period” has not been defined.

Incidentally, the Centre came to Court asking these questions and seeking a judicial determination of the same. The Court has always sidestepped this issue in its past decisions on promotional reservation by saying these are issues that fall within the executive’s policy making domain.

So going ahead, the Centre will have to seek expert opinion by forming a Committee that could examine these aspects. This means, the last word on this issue is yet to be out. Any decision to be taken by the Government will also be subject to review by the Court.

The judgment can be explained in six questions and the answers to it:

1. How to gather quantifiable data on inadequate representation of SCs and STs in public employment? 

No yardstick can be laid down by Court for determining the adequacy of SC/ST representation 

2. What is the unit to measure this data?

Cadre should be the unit for collection of quantifiable data and not the entire service as a unit.

3. What is the test to determine that SC/ST are unrepresented in promotional posts?

State should take into account relevant factors to assess inadequacy of representation of SC/ST.

4. Should there be a time period to review inadequacy of representation? 

Data collected to determine inadequacy needs to be reviewed periodically within reasonable period.

5. Whether judgment in M. Nagaraj (2006) should apply to appointments made prior to this date? 

M. Nagaraj decision will be prospective

6. Was decision in B.K. Pavitra v. Union of India (2019) decided wrongly?

B.K. Pavitra was decided wrongly as it approved collection of data on basis of ‘groups’ and not cadre.

Root Woot | Online Puja Samagri Root Woot | Online Puja Samagri Root Woot | Online Puja Samagri

In Numbers

49.4 %
Female Literacy rate of Scheduled Tribes

Web Stories

Bastar’s Famed Tuma Craft On Verge Of Extinction
Bastar’s Famed Tuma Craft On Verge Of Extinction
By The Indian Tribal
7 Tribal-linked Odisha Products Get GI Tag
7 Tribal-linked Odisha Products Get GI Tag
By The Indian Tribal
Traditional Attire Of Pawara Tribeswomen Losing Its Charm
Traditional Attire Of Pawara Tribeswomen Losing Its Charm
By The Indian Tribal
Tuma Art Going Extinct
Tuma Art Going Extinct
By The Indian Tribal

Update

Two Years Of Ethnic Violence In Manipur, Normalcy Still Elusive

It was on May 3 in 2023 that ethnic clashes broke out between the Meteis and the Kukis. They have since left more than 260 people killed, 1,500 injured, and over 70,000 people displaced. A shutdown called by Meitei group Coordinating Committee on Manipur Integrity (COCOMI) on Saturday (May 3) to mark two years of the ethnic strife in the northeastern State affected normal lives in the Meitei-controlled Imphal Valley. Life in the Kuki-dominated hill districts was also affected due to the shutdown by Zomi Students Federation (ZSF) and the Kuki Students Organisation (KSO).
Mahua flowers, The Indian Tribal
Adivasi

Of Summers, Mahua And Tribals

by The Indian Tribal
April 20, 2025

From juicy flowers bursting with flavours to drying and ending up as an intoxicating brew in bottles as liquor, Mahua’s story is deep, beyond ornamentation and intrinsic to tribal culture, writes Deepanwita Gita Niyogi

The Indian Tribal

Once Much Sought-After, Santali Jatra Troupes Gasping For Breath Now

March 19, 2025
The Indian Tribal

Tribal Woman Achiever: Youngest Minister In Hemant Soren Government

March 8, 2025
झारखंड सरकार के वित्त मंत्री राधा कृष्ण किशोर ने सोमवार को 1 लाख 45 हजार 400 करोड़ रुपये का वार्षिक बजट प्रस्तुत किया।

झारखंड में बनेगा जनजातीय विश्वविद्यालय 

March 3, 2025
The Indian Tribal

सौर ऊर्जा ने भगाया अंधेरा, झिलमिला उठे आदिवासियों के भविष्य के सपने

February 22, 2025
The Indian Tribal

Sexagenarian Tribal Devotes Life To Rod Puppetry

February 16, 2025
Previous Post

Stepping Up Welfare Measures in J&K

Next Post

The Gujjar Academic

Top Stories

The Indian Tribal
Adivasi

Reluctant Tribals Try Their Hands On Strawberry Farming In Odisha

April 26, 2025
Mahua flowers, The Indian Tribal
Adivasi

Of Summers, Mahua And Tribals

April 20, 2025
The Indian Tribal
Achievers

Once Much Sought-After, Santali Jatra Troupes Gasping For Breath Now

March 19, 2025
Load More
Next Post
The Indian Tribal, Jammu and Kashmir, Dr Javaid Rahi

The Gujjar Academic

  • About Us
  • Contact
  • Team
  • Redressal
  • Copyright Policy
  • Privacy Policy And Terms Of Use
  • Disclaimer
  • Sitemap

  • Achievers
  • Cuisine
  • Health
  • Hindi Featured
  • India
  • News
  • Legal
  • Music
  • Sports
  • Trending
  • Chhattisgarh
  • Delhi
  • Gujarat
  • Jammu & Kashmir
  • Jharkhand
  • Kerala
  • Madhya Pradesh
  • Maharashtra
  • North East
  • Arunachal Pradesh
  • Assam
  • Manipur
  • Meghalaya
  • Mizoram
  • Nagaland
  • Sikkim
  • Tripura
  • Odisha
  • Telangana
  • West Bengal
  • Political News
  • Variety
  • Art & Culture
  • Entertainment
  • Adivasi
  • Tribal News
  • Scheduled Tribes
  • हिंदी
  • उपलब्धिकर्ता
  • कानूनी
  • खान पान
  • खेलकूद
  • स्वास्थ्य
  • संस्कृति
  • संगीत
  • विविध
  • कला और संस्कृति
  • खबरें
  • असम की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • अरुणाचल प्रदेश की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • ओडिशा की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • केरल की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • गुजरात की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • छत्तीसगढ़
  • जम्मू और कश्मीर की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • झारखंड न्यूज़
  • तेलंगाना की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • दिल्ली
  • नॉर्थईस्ट की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • पश्चिम बंगाल की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • मध्य प्रदेश की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • महाराष्ट्र की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • त्रिपुरा की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • नागालैंड की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • मणिपुर की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • मिजोरम की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • मेघालय की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • सिक्किम की ताज़ा ख़बरें
  • राजस्थान की ताज़ा ख़बरें

About Us

The Indian Tribal is India’s first bilingual (English & Hindi) digital journalistic venture dedicated exclusively to the Scheduled Tribes. The ambitious, game-changer initiative is brought to you by Madtri Ventures Pvt Ltd (www.madtri.com). From the North East to Gujarat, from Kerala to Jammu and Kashmir — our seasoned journalists bring to the fore life stories from the backyards of the tribal, indigenous communities comprising 10.45 crore members and constituting 8.6 percent of India’s population as per Census 2011. Unsung Adivasi achievers, their lip-smacking cuisines, ancient medicinal systems, centuries-old unique games and sports, ageless arts and crafts, timeless music and traditional musical instruments, we cover the Scheduled Tribes community like never-before, of course, without losing sight of the ailments, shortcomings and negatives like domestic abuse, alcoholism and malnourishment among others plaguing them. Know the unknown, lesser-known tribal life as we bring reader-engaging stories of Adivasis of India.

Follow Us

All Rights Reserved

© 2024 Madtri Ventures [P] Ltd.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Achievers
  • Cuisine
  • Health
  • Health
  • Legal
  • Music
  • News
  • Sports
  • Variety
  • हिंदी
    • उपलब्धिकर्ता
    • खान पान
    • कानूनी
    • खेलकूद
    • खेलकूद
    • संगीत
    • संगीत
    • स्वास्थ्य
    • स्वास्थ्य
    • विविध
  • Gallery
  • Videos

© 2024 Madtri Ventures [P] Ltd.

Bastar’s Famed Tuma Craft On Verge Of Extinction 7 Tribal-linked Odisha Products Get GI Tag Traditional Attire Of Pawara Tribeswomen Losing Its Charm Tuma Art Going Extinct